2014Äê4ÔÂÃÀ¹úThe Manhattan Institute Ðû²¼ÁËÒ»Ïî¶ÔÃÀ¹úFDAÐÂÒ©ÉóÅúЧÂÊÆÀ¼ÛµÄÑо¿±¨¸æ£¬Ñо¿±¨¸æ³ÆÃÀ¹úFDAÒ©ÎïÆÀ¼ÛÓëÑо¿ÖÐÐÄ£¨Center for Drug Evaluation and Research £¬CDER£©²î±ðÒ©ÎïÉóÅú²¿·ÖÖ®¼äµÄÐÂÒ©ÉóÆÀʱ¼ä±£´æÒ»¶¨µÄ²î±ð£¬Òò´ËËûÃÇÒÔΪһЩ²¿·Ö±ÈÆäËû²¿·ÖµÄÊÂÇé¸ü¡°¸»ÓÐЧ¹û¡±¡£
ÄÇôÕâÏîÑо¿½áÂÛÊÇ·ñÄܹ»Õ¾µÄס½Å£¿ÐÂÒ©ÉóÆÀʱ¼äµÄ²î±ðÊÇ·ñÊÇÓÉÊÂÇéЧÂʾöÒéµÄÄØ£¿ÃÀ¹úFDAµÄ¿ÆÑÐְԱʹÓÃ×ÔÉíµÄÊý¾Ý¾ÙÐÐÆÊÎö£¬»Ø¸²Á˲î±ð²¿·ÖÖ®¼äÐÂÒ©ÉóÆÀʱ¼ä²î±ðµÄȪԴ¡£
Êý¾ÝºÍÑо¿ÒªÁì
FDAµÄÒ»¸öÖ÷ÒªÖ°ÔðÊÇʹ»¼ÕßÄܹ»¸ü¿ìµÄ»ñµÃÁ¢ÒìÐÔµÄÐÂÒ©¡£¿É¼ÓËÙÉóÆÀÌáǰÉÏÊеÄÐÂÒ©ÍùÍù¾ßÓÐÒÔÏÂÌØµã
:1£©ÓÃÀ´ÖÎÁÆÒ»Ð©ÑÏÖØ»òΣ¼°ÉúÃüµÄ¼²²¡;2£©Ìî²¹ÁËδ֪×ãµÄÒ½ÁÆÐèÇó£»3£©ÓëÏÖÓÐÒ©ÎïÏà±È£¬ÔÚÇå¾²ÐÔ»òÓÐÓÃÐÔ·½Ãæ»ñµÃÏÔÖø¸ÄÉÆ¡£FDAͨ¹ýÈý¸öÊÖ¶ÎÀ´Ëõ¶ÌÁ¢ÒìÒ©ÎïµÄÉóÆÀʱ¼ä:ÓÅÏÈÉóÆÀ¡¢¿ìËÙͨµÀÈ϶¨ºÍÍ»ÆÆÐÔÒ©ÎïÈ϶¨¡£ÀýÈç,ÓÅÏÈÉóÆÀ»®¶¨FDA¶ÔÐÂÒ©ÉÏÊÐÉêÇëÉóÆÀʱ¼äΪ6¸öÔÂ,¶ø±ê×¼ÉóÆÀµÄʱ¼äΪ10¸öÔ¡£ÃÀ¹úFDAµÄ¿ÆÑÐְԱʹÓÃFDAÄÚ²¿µÄÊý¾Ý¿â£¬Í³¼ÆÁË2002Äê10ÔÂÖÁ2012Äê9ÔÂ30ÈÕÕâ¶Îʱ¼äÄÚÏòÃÀ¹úFDAÌá½»µÄËùÓÐС·Ö×ÓзÖ×ÓʵÌåÒ©ÎïºÍÉúÎïзÖ×ÓʵÌåÒ©ÎïµÄÐÂÒ©ÉêÇ룬²¢ÅÌËãÁËÐÂÒ©µÄÉóÆÀʱ¼ä¡£
2002-2012ÄêFDAÊÕµ½²¢Åú×¼250¸öзÖ×ÓʵÌåÒ©ÎïµÄÐÂÒ©ÉêÇë,ÆäÖÐ117¸öÒ©ÎïΪÓÅÏÈÉóÆÀ,87¸öÒ©Îï»ñµÃ¿ìËÙͨµÀÈ϶¨£¬1¸öÒ©Îï»ñµÃÍ»ÆÆÐÔÒ©ÎïÈ϶¨¡£±í1ºÍͼ1¡¢Í¼2ΪFDA CDER ²î±ð²¿·ÖÊÕµ½µÄÐÂÒ©ÉÏÊÐÉêÇëÊýÄ¿ÒÔ¼°ÏìÓ¦µÄÉóÆÀÖÐλʱ¼ä¡£Ñо¿·¢Ã÷²î±ð²¿·ÖÐÂÒ©ÉóÆÀʱ¼äÊǷǵIJî±ð£¬ÊÇÓÉÐÂÒ©µÄһЩ×ÔÉíÌØÕ÷¾öÒéµÄ¡£Ò»Ð©²¿·ÖÐÂÒ©ÉóÆÀʱ¼äÖ®ÒÔÊǶ̣¬ÊÇÓÉÓÚÕâЩ²¿·ÖÎüÊÕµ½¸ü¶àÇкϼÓËÙÉóÆÀ±ê×¼µÄÐÂÒ©¡£
±í1 2002-2012ÄêÃÀ¹úFDA CDER²î±ð²¿·ÖÐÂÒ©ÉóÆÀʱ¼ä¸Å¿ö
Êý¾ÝȪԴ£ºNat Rev Drug Discov. 2015 Oct;14(10):670-1
ÓÅÏÈÉóÆÀÐÂÒ©ÊýÄ¿¶ÔÉóÆÀʱ¼äµÄÓ°Ïì
ͼ1 2002-2012ÄêÃÀ¹úFDA CDER ²î±ð²¿·ÖÓÅÏÈÉóÆÀÐÂÒ©ÊýÄ¿ºÍÉóÅúʱ¼ä
Êý¾ÝȪԴ£ºNat Rev Drug Discov. 2015 Oct;14(10):670-1
´Óͼ1ÖÐÎÒÃÇ¿ÉÒÔ¿´³öFDA CDER ²î±ð²¿·ÖµÄÉóÆÀÖÐλʱ¼äÓëÓÅÏÈÉóÆÀÐÂÒ©ÊýÄ¿³ÊºÜÇ¿µÄ¸ºÏà¹ØÐÔ¡£¿¹²¡¶¾Ò©£¨75%£©¡¢Ö×ÁöÒ©Î84%£©¡¢ÑªÒºÒ©Î61%£©ÓÅÏÈÉóÆÀÒ©Îï±ÈÀý×î¸ß£¬FDAÉóÆÀÖÐλʱ¼ä×î¶Ì£¬¿¹²¡¶¾Ò©FDAÉóÆÀÖÐλʱ¼äΪ182Ì죬Ö×ÁöÒ©ÎïFDAÉóÆÀÖÐλʱ¼äΪ182Ì죬ѪҺҩÎïFDAÉóÆÀÖÐλʱ¼äΪ273Ìì¡£Á½¸ö±äÁ¿Ö®¼äµÄƤ¶ûÑ·Ïà¹ØÏµÊý£¨Pearson correlation coefficient£©Îª?0.73£¬ÕâÒâζ×ÅFDA CDER²î±ð²¿·ÖÆÀÉóÖÐλʱ¼ä53%((?0.73) 2 )µÄ²î±ðÊÇÓÉÓÅÏÈÆÀÉóÐÂÒ©ÊýÄ¿¾öÒéµÄ¡£
¿ìËÙͨµÀÈ϶¨ÐÂÒ©ÊýÄ¿¶ÔÉóÆÀʱ¼äµÄÓ°Ïì
ͼ2 2002-2012ÄêÃÀ¹úFDA CDER ²î±ð²¿·Ö¿ìËÙͨµÀ×ʸñÈ϶¨Ò©ÎïÉóÅúʱ¼ä¸Å¿ö
Êý¾ÝȪԴ£ºNat Rev Drug Discov. 2015 Oct;14(10):670-1
´Óͼ2ÖÐÎÒÃÇ¿ÉÒÔ¿´³öFDA CDER ²î±ð²¿·ÖµÄÉóÆÀÖÐλʱ¼äÓë¿ìËÙͨµÀÈ϶¨ÐÂÒ©ÊýÄ¿³ÊºÜÇ¿µÄ¸ºÏà¹ØÐÔ¡£¿¹²¡¶¾Ò©£¨58%£©¡¢Ö×ÁöÒ©Î75%£©¡¢ÑªÒºÒ©Î71%£©¿ìËÙͨµÀÈ϶¨ÐÂÒ©±ÈÀý×î¸ß£¬FDAÉóÆÀÖÐλʱ¼ä×î¶Ì£¬¿¹²¡¶¾Ò©FDAÉóÅúÖÐλʱ¼äΪ182Ì죬Ö×ÁöÒ©ÎïFDAÉóÅúÖÐλʱ¼äΪ182Ì죬ѪҺҩÎïFDAÉóÅúÖÐλʱ¼äΪ273Ìì¡£Á½¸ö±äÁ¿Ö®¼äµÄƤ¶ûÑ·Ïà¹ØÏµÊý£¨Pearson correlation coefficient£©Îª?0.61£¬ÕâÒâζ×ÅFDA CDER²î±ð²¿·ÖÉóÆÀÖÐλʱ¼ä37%((?0.73) 2 )µÄ²î±ðÊÇÓÉ¿ìËÙͨµÀ×ÊÈ϶¨ÐÂÒ©ÊýÄ¿¾öÒéµÄ¡£
Ñо¿½áÂÛ
FDAÊý¾ÝÆÊÎöЧ¹ûÅú×¢, »ñµÃ¸ü¶àÓÅÏÈÉóÆÀÐÂÒ©»ò¿ìËÙͨµÀÈ϶¨ÐÂÒ©µÄ²¿·Ö£¬ÈçÖ×ÁöÒ©ÉóÅú²¿·ÖºÍ¿¹²¡¶¾Ò©ÉóÅú²¿·Ö£¬ÐÂÒ©µÄƽ¾ùÉóÆÀʱ¼ä¸ü¶Ì¡£Õâµãȱ·¦ÎªÆæ£¬ÓÉÓÚÐÂÒ©×ÔÉíÐÔ×ÓºÍÖÎÁƼ²²¡ÌصãµÄ²î±ð£¬²î±ðÐÂÒ©ÉóÆÀ²¿·ÖµÄÓÅÏÈÉóÆÀÐÂÒ©ºÍ¿ìËÙͨµÀÈ϶¨ÐÂÒ©ÊýÄ¿±£´æ½Ï´óµÄ²î±ð¡£ÈçÓëÖ×ÁöÏà±È£¬Æ¤·ô²¡ºÍÑÀ¿Æ¼²²¡ºÜÉÙÌØÊâÑÏÖØ»òΣ¼°ÉúÃü£¬Òò´Ëͨ¹ý¿ìËÙÉóÆÀ;¾¶ÉóÆÀµÄÐÂÒ©½ÏÉÙ£¬ÐÂÒ©ÉóÆÀʱ¼äÒ²³¤ÓÚÖ×ÁöÐÂÒ©µÄÉóÆÀʱ¼ä¡£±ðµÄ£¬Ò»Ð©¼²²¡ÁìÓò¸üÓпÉÄÜÔÚÒ»¸öÌØ¶¨µÄʱÆÚ±¬·¢ÖØ´óµÄ¿Æ¼¼Í»ÆÆ,Òò¶ø»áËæÖ®±¬·¢´ó×ÚµÄÍ»ÆÆÐÔµÄÐÂÒ©£¬Èç×î½ü±ûÐ͸ÎÑ×ÉÏÊÐÁËһϵÁÐÍ»ÆÆÐÔµÄÐÂÒ©¡£Òò´Ë£¬²»¿É°ÑÐÂÒ©ÉóÆÀʱ¼äµÄÊÇ·ÇÀ´×÷Ϊ FDA CDER ²î±ð²¿·ÖÊÂÇéЧÂÊÆéá«ÆÀ¼ÛµÄÖ¸±ê¡£